The Movie vs. The Book: My Sister's Keeper

With a friend who has also read the book, we watched the movie version of the book My Sister's Keeper by Jodi Picoult on Friday.

The movie was released in 2009, and some of the cast list is as follows:

Anna Fitzgerald - Abigail Breslin
Sara Fitzgerald - Cameron Diaz
Kate Fitzgerald - Sofia Vassilieva
Taylor Ambrose - Thomas Dekker
Campbell Alexander - Alec Baldwin

If I had not read the book, I would have liked this movie. The basic plotline was the same, but several of the key characters from the book were left out such as Julia Romano. Also, Kate, Anna, and Jesse looked too young when compared to how I pictured them. Several of the events were rushed and disjointed and the ending of the movie was also completely different than the book.

On the positive side, this movie was full of emotion. Some parts were very sad, and made me want to cry. While others, sparked laughter.

Again, this movie was great by itself, but when compared with the book, it did not reach my expectations.

Click here to read my review of the book, My Sister's Keeper

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Best Books of 2015: Historical Fiction

Image
Today marks the second "Best of" list of 2015. Having revealed my Best Autobiography / Memoir / Nonfiction books yesterday, today will be the Best Historical Fiction. None of the novels on this list were a disappointment, in fact I had a very difficult time deciding which spot each would take.  A God in Ruins was just as intricate and spellbinding as its companion novel, Life After Life . The Secret Life of Violet Grant was the perfect vacation read -- full of adventure and drama. I was completely invested in Anita Diamant's beautifully feminist book, The Red Tent , and was pleased to find that her most recent novel, The Boston Girl , was just as thrilling. The novel you will find at #1 is the perfect combination of all of these books -- its story is both elegantly written and undoubtedly important.  Top Historical Fiction of 2015: 8. Beloved , by Toni Morrison 7. The Poisonwood Bible , by Barbara Kingsolver 6. The Secret Life of Violet Grant , b...
Read more

Where She Went

Image
Where She Went Gayle Forman 260 pages "Her eyes were closed, and her brow was a little furrowed. She was so still, it seemed like she'd taken a brief vacation from her body...I somehow knew then she was listening to music then, was grabbing the notes from the silence...I stood there, riveted by her, until she seemed to wake up and start playing with this intense concentration."  Four years after the accident, Mia and Adam have gone separate ways.  Mia tries to put the pieces of her life back together as she studies at Julliard, while Adam struggles to find comfort in the whirlwind of his rockstar-celebrity life. By a stroke of chance, the two are brought together for one night, and although their hours are short, together Mia and Adam explore the city, and who they have become. Gayle Forman's sequel to the New York Times Bestseller If I Stay , is written through Adam's voice, in that raw prose which defines her novels. I enjoyed this change in point of v...
Read more

What My English Teacher Said

As I think I stated in a previous post, my English class had been reading the famous play The Crucible by Arthur Miller. The Crucible was written in 1953, in the midst of The Cold War, but with a setting during the Salem Witch Trials which took place in the 1690s. I finished the story a few weeks ago, but we completed watching the film just yesterday. Right after the final scene, when John Proctor, Rebecca Nurse, and Martha Corey are hung, my teacher stopped the film for a minute or two, at the very final image: a close-up of the rope, against a beautiful bluebird sky. At this point, the whole class was trying to stifle their tears, but she just turned to us and said, "Write." She then continued to say, "Write about the rope. What's the point? Channel your emotions, and write." She gave us about ten minutes or so before we shared them out loud, but I've taken the time to develop my piece a bit more here: The Rope A rope is something strong and roug...
Read more